Fried Fish Sandwich with Tartar Sauce

March 07, 2025

Fried Fish Sandwich with Tartar Sauce

Sure to be a spring staple on your dinner menu this Legal Seafood recipe for fried fish sandwich is easy to put together quickly.  Be sure and grab a jar of tartar sauce from our party pantry online or in store!  Feeds four.

Ingredients

  • ½ cup white cornmeal
  • ½ cup flour
  • ¼ teaspoon dry mustard
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 3 cups canola oil
  • 1 ½ 2 pounds haddock or cod, cut into 4 pieces
  • 1 cup buttermilk
  • 4 bulkie rolls
  • Lettuce
  • Sliced Tomato
  • Legal Sea Foods Chipotle or House Tartar Sauce
  1. In a small bowl mix together the cornmeal, flour, dry mustard and salt to make the fried fish coating and set aside.
  2. Heat the oil in a heavy, deep, nonreactive pan (or a deep-fat fryer) until it reaches 365°F.
  3. Meanwhile, submerge the fish into the buttermilk.  Remove and dip into the coating mixture, covering all areas of the fish.  Gently shake the pieces to remove any excess coating and place on a dish next to your frying area.
  4. Test the oil using a deep fat thermometer to make sure it is at 365°F. Gently lower the fish pieces into the oil a few at a time, being sure not to overcrowd the oil as that will make the temperature drop.  When the fish begins to brown, flip them over and continue to fry until golden brown.
  5. Remove the fish from the oil, sprinkle with salt if desired.  Continue to fry the rest of the fish, checking the oil temperature before adding each batch of fish.
  6. Split the buns in half and spread the bottom half with tartar sauce.  Top with a piece of fried fish, lettuce, tomato and the top of the bun.  Serve immediately with additional tartar sauce if desired.

Adapted from the Legal Sea Foods Cookbook





Leave a comment


Also in Welcome to the Table

Bluegrass BBQ Menu and Recipes
Bluegrass BBQ Menu and Recipes

June 13, 2026

View full article →

Sea Shores Dinner Menu & Recipes
Sea Shores Dinner Menu & Recipes

June 05, 2026

A beautifully set coastal table is the first course of any dinner party. It tells your guests they are somewhere special — that someone took the time, that this evening was made just for them. Our Sea Shores collection was designed exactly for this kind of moment: layered, serene, and full of the kind of coastal beauty that feels effortless and collected all at once.

View full article →

Beeutiful by Design Farmers Market Summer Dinner menu
Farmers Market Summer Dinner — A Garden to Table Celebration

May 26, 2026

A warm-weather dinner party guide featuring our Garden to Table collection, a farmers market-inspired menu, and all the Stonewall Kitchen pantry staples you need to pull it off beautifully.

View full article →